Mind Control Comics Forum

The Letters Page -- WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS => Saint James Infirmary => Topic started by: Daphne on May 26, 2013, 07:39:24 pm



Title: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Daphne on May 26, 2013, 07:39:24 pm
Coming Tuesday, May 28th!


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on May 27, 2013, 01:50:46 pm
Who are the guest artists this time around?


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Daphne on May 27, 2013, 04:10:02 pm
Who are the guest artists this time around?

Oops! MB and Sorenka are doing the full run until PK's return.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on May 28, 2013, 12:09:56 am
So this is early '07 that we're looking at?  Pearl is somewhere between 23 and 24 currently?  And the whole "Miriam" thing was a reaction to the trauma of whatever got Q-box busted?  Confusing.  Intersting, but confusing...as ever.

Incidentally, I know the title is a play on words, but aren't we referring more to "rights" than "rites" here?


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on May 28, 2013, 11:56:12 am
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on May 28, 2013, 05:43:43 pm
Actually, that's an old trait of hers that we broke with Forget Something? Part 2.  She had this armor of sort of wounded sarcasm and bitterness that was an imposing wall of black that blocked out her (gorgeous) face.  Maybe this is all a reaction to Q-Box, because frankly, this guest page is more like Gilmore Girls the Punk Rock Edition than an angst disaster.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on May 29, 2013, 11:42:32 am
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Werdna on May 30, 2013, 09:51:08 am
Quote
Maybe this is all a reaction to Q-Box

The thing that most struck me about these two guest strips is how happy and together Jacqui is, contrasted with her early appearances in the main SJI storyline.  She is combative in both, though playfully (with Q and Pearl) in the issues set years earlier, and angrily afterwards.  It reminds me of the Erin depicted with her school buddies (pre-Wilmot) vs early, angry Erin, actually.

I think Q must have used Pink Clouds on Jacqui, possibly (probably?) extensively, warping her in the process.  MC done by the bad guys seems to result in psychic scarring (for lack of a better word) - we see that with Dani, for example, as well as with Laura (to some extent, I would argue), and we still don't know exactly what happened to Erin.  I think Jacqui's change in personality from these strips to the early SJI issues is a result of similar mental trauma.

Adrian's mind control over his harem is curative of the other forms of MC, and is helping to restore these people to a version of themselves that's happier and better adjusted.

Just my latest crackpot theory, expressed badly.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on May 30, 2013, 12:30:26 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Werdna on May 30, 2013, 12:57:18 pm
Well, maybe not "happy", but definitely, i don't know, less angry?  Erin's early descriptions of Jacqui, and her behaviour, is hardly like the person we see here - in a good relationship with her daughter, in a relationship with Q where they are both pursuing their interests and (apparently) trying to work how things can work out for them.  The Jacqui we see in the shadows of the early comic punches out Derek (for good reason) and Erin acts as though this is just a standard kind of thing, with a scary boss who is willing to do that to people who piss her off.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on May 30, 2013, 03:55:17 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 03, 2013, 11:48:47 am
Not sure why but I haven't been able to see the comic images on either my pc or PK's PC for a couple of months - I see the front pages but not the actual pages...just a mean little X where my image should be (same on PK's computer)...

So, I haven't read any of the guest pages and have just 'guessed' what's the story :)

I think you are right, GW...strong women don't admire neediness in a man...I have to say though, I'm not sure Jacqui is strong. She's very needy herself and aggressive rather than assertive  - I don't know if I think any of the women in the Infirmary are 'strong' in my sense of the word...but maybe that's a debate for another time....

I wish I could see the pages :(

I should point out that I have no input into the story and have no idea of plots past, present or future :) Just an interested observer....also looking forward to PK's return x


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Daphne on June 03, 2013, 02:04:04 pm
So, I haven't read any of the guest pages and have just 'guessed' what's the story :)

Customer service is just an email away. :)


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 03, 2013, 02:27:09 pm

Customer service is just an email away. :)

Oh...I don't think it's to do with the site, D...I think it's more likely to do with a compatibiity issue or having my settings changed when my PC decided to download and install IE10...or something....


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on June 03, 2013, 03:41:48 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 04, 2013, 04:07:03 am
I agree...I know some strong women and some of them consider me to be a strong woman - but aggressive isn't assertive, and I consider the ability to be assertive a strong characteristic (if that's the right term). Weeping over your croissant because your boyfriend left without waking you up is, to me a pretty weak and pathetic trait - or behaviour. I may be just saying this because I like her and am (probably) like her, but I consider Dani to be the strongest of the SJI women. I like self reliant, capable women - lippy in one hand and hammer drill in the other...yummy :D

BTW...thanks to Daphne for sorting out the image problem - I've now had a chance to read the pages. I have no take on this bit of the puzzle, though...I may be flummoxed!!! But I did like the art, very much...


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Daphne on June 04, 2013, 07:41:33 am
Weeping over your croissant because your boyfriend left without waking you up is, to me a pretty weak and pathetic trait - or behaviour.

Hey, no one's perfect. :)


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on June 04, 2013, 12:26:46 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 04, 2013, 01:08:05 pm
With the proviso that I don't know what it means, I see Mallory as the strongest woman. I'm not sure if Rain is actually human but if she does count then she probably wins hands down.

So...given that you don't think you know what it means, why Mallory? I mean what is it about her that you read as strong?


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on June 04, 2013, 03:46:02 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on June 04, 2013, 06:41:32 pm
I don't know that we know enough about Mallory to make pronouncements that grand.  And really, I think it was her education, not her job selection where she broke with her parents.

I'm not sure I can really see where Dani ends and her programming begins, but Erin is multi-skilled and quite self-sufficient.  I don't neccessarily know that building up emotional walls and armors of sarcasm in response to severe trauma is really a sign of weakness, but that's a disucssion for a different moment.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 04, 2013, 11:26:03 pm
I suppose based on what I said earlier, my definition of a strong person must be someone who gets what he or she wants without posturing. But actually I think a strong person is someone who can deal with not getting what he or she wants. A strong person can fail and deal with it.

Mallory has made her own way in life. She applied for and took a job her family didn't want her to take. She's comfortable with - and open about - her sexuality. She seems to live life on her terms and to have the life she wanted. But she also seems like she can deal with the stuff she didn't want. Some people just leave you to get on with deciding whether you like them (the opposite of needy?). Mallory strikes me as that kind of person.

Wow...and you say you don't think you know what it means :) I have a degree in psychology and I couldn't have written it better...and, you know what, I think you convinced me. Mallory does tend to just quietly get on with things and let others run around worrying...

I don't know about Erin being multi-skilled, though, Jmundt29....trying to think what skills she's displayed other than singing, crying and f***ing :D


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: GodWilling on June 05, 2013, 12:54:21 pm
.


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: Daphne on June 05, 2013, 12:56:23 pm
trying to think what skills she's displayed other than singing, crying and f***ing :D

Well, she can act. :)


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on June 05, 2013, 07:03:03 pm
As I understand it, she can act and sing quite well.  Also, could we revisit for a moment the reason why everyone is suddenly equating Erin Hackberry with Sally Brown?  I don't remember her crying in any instance, except just after Dani popped out of that closet (and maybe as part of that "summoning" she escaped in the GP flashback).  Dani has awakened screaming and crying a couple times, but I'm not hearing anyone criticize her for it.  What gives?


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: OctaviaMoon on June 05, 2013, 10:31:14 pm
Maybe I am being a bit tough on poor Erin...who, until this particular incident I thought she was pretty cool. The incident in question is on page 174...where she weeps over her morning coffee because Adrian went to his music lesson without waking her up for a boink!! Whilst I completely understand her disappointment, I think it probably only warranted a bit of a grumble....maybe she was acting :)


Title: Re: Saint James Infirmary Guest Page 17: Visitation Rites
Post by: jmundt29 on June 07, 2013, 11:45:40 am
I...well, I took another look at 174, I guess you're talking about two panels before we hear Dani's wake-up scream.  The first panel is definitely sarcastic Erin at her finest.  The slumping in her chair in panel...what, 3 shows her as more upset than sarcatic.  I think the combination of the slump and then the head in hands gives the wrong impression.  She gives off depressed, but she's not crying (and I don't think she's just barely holding back tears) but the combination of disappointment, and frustration has her at sea.  I've known people to have their heads in their hands rubbing their eyes when overtired or exceptionally frustrated, or both--higher education (particularly law school) can do that to a person.